Home > Calculators > Heating Cost Comparison Calculator
Compare what gas, oil, propane, electric resistance heating and a heat pump would each cost to run in your home in the USA, UK and Canada, ranked cheapest first. Enter your heat demand and local prices — no sign-up, no email, just the numbers.
Five ways to heat the same home can differ by thousands a year in running costs — but these are running costs only, and installation is where the options differ most. A heat pump is often cheapest or close to it, yet where natural gas is cheap it can rank second or lower, and this calculator will show you that plainly rather than hide it.
For each of the five heating options, the annual cost is worked out the same way:
Annual cost = annual heat demand (kWh) × (fuel price ÷ energy per unit of fuel in kWh) ÷ (efficiency ÷ 100).
For gas, oil and propane, the price, energy content and efficiency come from the figures you enter. Electric resistance heating uses your electricity rate with an efficiency of 100%. The heat pump also uses your electricity rate, with its efficiency set to COP × 100 — so a COP of 3.0 counts as 300% efficiency, because it moves heat rather than making it. All five results are then ranked cheapest first.
The fairest way to compare fuels is the cost of one kWh of heat actually delivered to your home, after efficiency. At US defaults the ranking is:
| Heating option | Cost per kWh of delivered heat (US defaults) |
|---|---|
| Natural gas | $0.054 |
| Heat pump (COP 3.0) | $0.061 |
| Heating oil | $0.104 |
| Propane | $0.122 |
| Electric resistance | $0.183 |
Gas is cheapest per unit of heat at these prices, with the heat pump close behind. Oil, propane and direct electric heat cost far more per unit. Your own rates can change this order, so use the calculator above with your local prices. If a heat pump looks right for you, see the Heat Pump Savings Calculator for install payback, the Heat Pump Balance Point Calculator for the temperature where backup heat takes over, and the Heat Pump Size Calculator for the size your home needs.
It depends on your local fuel prices. With the US defaults, natural gas is cheapest at $813 a year, ahead of a heat pump at $915. In Canada the heat pump wins at C$840 a year, just ahead of gas at C$853. Electric resistance heating is the most expensive option in all three countries.
A heat pump runs on electricity, which costs more per unit than gas in many places. It wins by efficiency: at COP 3.0 it delivers three units of heat for each unit of electricity. Where gas is very cheap, that efficiency advantage is not quite enough, and gas stays cheaper to run — this calculator shows that honestly.
Annual heat demand is the total heat your home needs in a year, measured in kWh. A typical US home uses around 15,000 kWh, a UK home around 12,000 kWh and a Canadian home around 18,000 kWh. You can estimate yours from a year of fuel bills: multiply the fuel you used by its energy content and your system's efficiency.
No. This calculator compares running costs only. Installation is where the options differ most — a heat pump usually costs far more to install than a like-for-like boiler or furnace replacement, though grants can close much of that gap. Weigh the running-cost ranking here against real installation quotes before deciding.
At US defaults, natural gas is the cheapest at $813/year, just ahead of a heat pump at $915/year. Oil, propane and electric resistance heating cost far more. The cheapest way for your home depends on your rates — run your own numbers in the calculator above to see your ranking.
Yes, by a wide margin at current prices. At US defaults the heat pump costs $915/year compared with oil at $1,565/year at $3.60/gallon. In parts of the US Northeast oil runs over $6/gallon, where the gap is wider.
Sources: US rates — EIA (US Energy Information Administration); UK prices — Ofgem price cap; Canada — Canada Energy Regulator; COP ranges — US Department of Energy.
Free to use on your own website with a credit link back to WattWorth Calc.