The two balance points, in plain English
1. Thermal balance point — about heat
Your home loses heat faster as it gets colder outside, and a heat pump produces less heat as it gets colder outside. The thermal balance point is the outdoor temperature where those two lines cross: the heat pump's capacity exactly matches your home's heat loss.
Above that temperature, the heat pump heats your home on its own. Below it, the heat pump cannot keep up alone, so backup heat (electric strips or a gas, oil or propane furnace) switches on to help.
2. Economic balance point — about money
A heat pump gets less efficient in cold weather. Its efficiency is measured as COP (coefficient of performance): a COP of 3 means 1 unit of electricity makes 3 units of heat. The economic balance point is the outdoor temperature where running the heat pump costs exactly the same as running the backup fuel.
Above it, the heat pump is the cheaper way to heat. Below it, the backup fuel is cheaper, so a dual-fuel system should switch over.
Why the confusion matters: a system can be well past its economic balance point — costing you more than gas — while still heating the home fine. And it can hit its thermal balance point on a very cold night even when the heat pump is still the cheapest option. They answer different questions.
Why it matters for your bills
Below the balance point, backup heat runs — and bills jump. Electric backup strips are the most expensive heat there is, and even a gas furnace costs more per unit of heat than a heat pump running efficiently. If your balance point is set too high, or your heat pump is undersized, you can spend a large part of winter on expensive backup heat without realising it. That is the most common reason a heat pump owner's bills disappoint.
Worked examples with real numbers
The economic balance point depends on one simple test: what COP does the heat pump need to match the backup fuel's cost? If that COP is higher than the heat pump can deliver, the backup is always cheaper. If it is lower than the heat pump's cold-day COP, the heat pump is always cheaper.
| Home & backup fuel | COP the heat pump must beat | Result |
|---|---|---|
| US home, gas backup | 3.38 | Economic balance point: 5.8 °C |
| UK home, gas backup | 3.82 | No balance point — gas is always cheaper |
| US home, oil backup | 1.75 | Heat pump always cheaper |
| US home, propane backup | 1.50 | Heat pump always cheaper |
US home vs gas: balance point 5.8 °C
With typical US electricity and gas prices, the heat pump must beat a COP of 3.38 to undercut gas. A typical heat pump delivers about COP 3.5 on a mild day but falls as temperatures drop. The two costs cross at about 5.8 °C. Above 5.8 °C, run the heat pump. Below it, gas is cheaper.
UK home vs gas: there is no balance point
In the UK, gas is cheap relative to electricity, so the heat pump would need a COP of 3.82 to match gas. That is above a typical heat pump's mild-day COP of 3.5 — it never gets there. The honest conclusion: on running cost alone, the gas backup is always cheaper in this example. A UK heat pump's case rests on carbon savings, boiler replacement costs and future price changes, not on beating gas today.
US home vs oil or propane: the heat pump always wins
Oil and propane are expensive fuels. The heat pump only needs a COP of 1.75 to beat oil, and 1.50 to beat propane. Even on a cold day, a heat pump delivers around COP 2.0 — comfortably above both. So there is no economic balance point: the heat pump is cheaper at every outdoor temperature, and backup should only run when the heat pump physically cannot keep up.
Find your own balance point
Enter your home size, insulation, heat pump and backup fuel prices. The calculator works out both balance points for the US, UK and Canada in seconds — free, no sign-up.
What to do about a high balance point
- Improve insulation first. Better insulation and draught-proofing reduce your home's heat loss, which pushes the thermal balance point down — the heat pump can cope alone to lower temperatures.
- Choose a cold-climate unit. Cold-climate heat pumps hold a higher COP and more capacity at low temperatures, lowering both balance points compared with a standard unit.
- Consider a dual-fuel setup. Pairing a heat pump with a gas furnace, and setting the switchover at the economic balance point, gives you the cheapest heat at every temperature: heat pump when it wins, gas when it doesn't.
- Size the system correctly. An undersized heat pump hits its thermal balance point early and leans on backup all winter. Check your home's heat load before you buy.
Use the Heat Pump Sizing Calculator → to see what size your home actually needs.
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between a thermal and an economic balance point?
The thermal balance point is about heat: the outdoor temperature where your heat pump's output exactly matches your home's heat loss. The economic balance point is about money: the temperature where running the heat pump costs the same as the backup fuel. They are usually different temperatures.
What is a good heat pump balance point?
Lower is generally better. A thermal balance point around or below freezing means the heat pump can heat the home alone for most of the winter. For the economic balance point, what matters is how often temperatures fall below it where you live — fewer backup hours means lower bills.
What happens below the balance point?
Below the thermal balance point, the heat pump cannot keep up on its own, so backup heat switches on to help. Below the economic balance point, the backup fuel is the cheaper option, so a well-set-up dual-fuel system switches to it automatically. This is when heating bills jump.
More WattWorth Calc guides
Prices and examples on this page use typical November 2026 US and UK energy prices. Your own balance point depends on your local prices, your home and your heat pump — use the calculator above for your numbers. WattWorth Calc is independent and sells nothing; the calculators exist so you can run the numbers yourself.